top of page

Celebrating Jonathan Bennett's Hallmark Movies

Jonathan Bennett, the unforgettable Aaron Samuels from "Mean Girls," has made a name for himself in the world of Hallmark movies. Some of his roles are not only charming but also bring genuine gay stories to the forefront. Let’s dive into some of his Hallmark highlights.

5 Jonathan Bennett Hallmark Movies to Watch

Poster for Hallmark's 'The Holiday Sitter' showing Jonathan Bennett and George Krissa with holiday decorations in the background, highlighting a cheerful holiday setting.

Synopsis: Sam is tasked with babysitting his niece and nephew before the holidays. When he seeks help from their handsome neighbor Jason, sparks fly, and an unexpected romance begins. This film is a cozy, festive watch that beautifully blends family dynamics and budding love.

Review: Bennett brings warmth and relatability to the role of Sam. The chemistry between him and George Krissa, who plays Jason, is delightful. It's a heartwarming story perfect for the holiday season, showcasing the magic of unexpected connections.

Promotional poster for Hallmark's 'The Christmas House' featuring Jonathan Bennett and the cast, highlighting a festive holiday scene with Christmas decorations and ornaments.

Synopsis: In this holiday tale, a mother and father call their two grown sons home for Christmas. Each son faces significant life changes, and the family works through these challenges together.

Review: This movie is a heartfelt exploration of family and personal growth. Bennett shines as one of the sons, bringing depth to his character's journey. It’s a touching story that balances holiday cheer with real-life issues.

Promotional poster for 'The Christmas House 2: Deck Those Halls' featuring Jonathan Bennett and cast members in a snowy, festive scene with Christmas decorations.

Synopsis: The Mitchell brothers are back, competing to create the best Christmas house. This friendly rivalry brings back holiday cheer and some sibling competition.

Review: This sequel amps up the festive fun with a spirited competition. Bennett’s performance adds a charming layer to the sibling dynamics. It’s a fun, light-hearted movie that will get you in the holiday spirit.

Promotional image for 'Christmas Made to Order' featuring Jonathan Bennett and Alexa PenaVega, standing in front of a decorated Christmas tree, smiling warmly.

Synopsis: Architect Steven finds himself hosting his family for Christmas. Overwhelmed, he hires holiday coordinator Gretchen to infuse his home with festive joy.

Review: Bennett and Alexa PenaVega create a delightful on-screen duo. The story is sweet and engaging, with plenty of holiday cheer. Bennett’s portrayal of Steven is both endearing and relatable, making this a must-watch for Christmas lovers.

Poster for Hallmark's 'Wedding of a Lifetime' starring Jonathan Bennett and Brooke D'Orsay. The poster shows the couple running a race in wedding attire with a joyous expression.

Synopsis: A recently separated couple accidentally enters a nationally televised contest competing for an all-expenses-paid wedding, leading them to rekindle their romance.

Review: Bennett’s role in this film brings a mix of humor and heart. The premise is fun, and the movie delivers plenty of feel-good moments. It’s a great pick for those who enjoy romantic comedies with a twist.

Jonathan Bennett's Hallmark movies bring warmth, charm, and a crucial voice for gay representation to the screen. Whether you're in the mood for holiday cheer or a feel-good romance, Bennett’s filmography offers something special for everyone.

Check out "I Married a Monster on a Hill" a Boys Love Universe Project


bottom of page